genesim thinks you're missing the point
Dec 7, 2017 2:23:00 GMT
Post by Mediocrates on Dec 7, 2017 2:23:00 GMT
The "Is there even an audience for new rock anymore?" thread is like flypaper for every sad sack Boomer with a grievance, and none is more misunderstood than this newcomer:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
Dmiller,
And again what is your point?
Let me give you an example The Star Spangled Banner Wild Thing and Machine Gun well like a Jackson Pollock paintings they were an expression that to imitate is completely missing the point.
So when I say stupid I am referring to pointless having no end.
Furthermore that statement was not personal attacking anyone.
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
genesim:
forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/is-there-even-an-audience-for-new-rock-anymore.643236
genesim:
That statement is a misnomer. If they have a voice of their own and they're able to do it in a way that sets it apart from the original then obviously it has merit.
You are trying to make absolutes out of my statements which I think we're very clear. Bring more to the table or it's not worth doing. That more can be their own distinct voice even if it seems like there is no creativity.
Now in some of the cases brought on here there is not only no distinct voice but there's no creativity... like a double whammy. Might as well just make a tape recording.
By the way I must stress again that when I bought those Jimi Hendrix examples I brought them up because they were very hard to imitate and could arguably never ever be repeated by Jimi Hendrix himself if he was alive to do it ....a point that I'm sure was missed.
You are trying to make absolutes out of my statements which I think we're very clear. Bring more to the table or it's not worth doing. That more can be their own distinct voice even if it seems like there is no creativity.
Now in some of the cases brought on here there is not only no distinct voice but there's no creativity... like a double whammy. Might as well just make a tape recording.
By the way I must stress again that when I bought those Jimi Hendrix examples I brought them up because they were very hard to imitate and could arguably never ever be repeated by Jimi Hendrix himself if he was alive to do it ....a point that I'm sure was missed.
genesim:
Once again you miss my point.
I am not speaking about artists doing reinditions, I am speaking about Chris' thoughts they are "better" or a replacement.
It is like you cherry pick my posts, twist them around and think that your blanket statement holds water or even relates to what I wrote. It really is getting old. What is this 3 times with zero effort to get it right?
I am not speaking about artists doing reinditions, I am speaking about Chris' thoughts they are "better" or a replacement.
It is like you cherry pick my posts, twist them around and think that your blanket statement holds water or even relates to what I wrote. It really is getting old. What is this 3 times with zero effort to get it right?
genesim:
It ain't the kid I am talking about. You missed the point too.
I suspect if you asked the kid even he would understand where I am coming from and the adulation to the point of replacement.
But again, the disrespectful name calling to me are not appreciated.
I suspect if you asked the kid even he would understand where I am coming from and the adulation to the point of replacement.
But again, the disrespectful name calling to me are not appreciated.
genesim:
Dmiller,
And again what is your point?
Let me give you an example The Star Spangled Banner Wild Thing and Machine Gun well like a Jackson Pollock paintings they were an expression that to imitate is completely missing the point.
So when I say stupid I am referring to pointless having no end.
Furthermore that statement was not personal attacking anyone.
genesim:
I said that Elvis rock roots are but a part and you say that I think Elvis Rock roots are not import???
Wow talk about the straw man of all straw man. I suggest you go back and read the context of what I wrote because there was nothing in there said anything close to what you stated.
Wow talk about the straw man of all straw man. I suggest you go back and read the context of what I wrote because there was nothing in there said anything close to what you stated.
genesim:
Please go back and read my post. You are completely confused.
I never once said there was any false reporting of any kind.
I never once said there was any false reporting of any kind.
genesim:
Take a look at the accusers last 10 posts for examples.
There was nothing hostile from me and others about having simple disagreements.
There was nothing hostile from me and others about having simple disagreements.
genesim:
Where did I say anything uncivilized or directed such behavior at another poster from me?
However, you have misstated my posts and asked direct antagonizing questions that serve no point but to actually distort what was said. Worse you actually ignore direct questions back to you as if it didn't happen.
It is trollish behavior and I ask that you take a look in the mirror.
Whatever I said that offended I straight up apologize. My distaste is aimed at the RIAAand Billboard that without question distort sales reflection (not accuracy) to appease waning music sales and to discredit pioneers.
Sorry if the truth comes off hostile.
However, you have misstated my posts and asked direct antagonizing questions that serve no point but to actually distort what was said. Worse you actually ignore direct questions back to you as if it didn't happen.
It is trollish behavior and I ask that you take a look in the mirror.
Whatever I said that offended I straight up apologize. My distaste is aimed at the RIAAand Billboard that without question distort sales reflection (not accuracy) to appease waning music sales and to discredit pioneers.
Sorry if the truth comes off hostile.
genesim:
It has been twice now and you still can't get it right
Here is what I said:
"His rock roots are but a part, and to contemporary country artists that were influenced by him...a much smaller part, but that is my opinion."
And then you respond with this???
Here is what I said:
"His rock roots are but a part, and to contemporary country artists that were influenced by him...a much smaller part, but that is my opinion."
And then you respond with this???
genesim:
I am not dissing Mr. Plant as an artist I have a problem with what he said about how I and others should support our rock tastes.
Xxxxxx
Williamwes,
See my previous post I covered all you said.
Xxxxxx
Williamwes,
See my previous post I covered all you said.
genesim:
Where you are wrong is that I somehow am discouraging of that. You need to go back and actually read instead of the knee jerk reaction.
genesim:
Actually I agree with you so not sure where you're going with that.
genesim:
What was this my take on new rock? I just posted what I liked, not what I thought was shaking up the world. Relax dude, like my username you are looking way too much into it.
forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/is-there-even-an-audience-for-new-rock-anymore.643236